The Old Stone Church~210 3rd St. Castle Rock, Co 80104
Let me begin by saying that the only eating I have ever done in the city of Castle Rock was about six years ago when I was forced to patronize a very sad, sad little Mexican restaurant which used Velveeta on its burritos, so, I wasn’t expecting much when we rolled into town looking for the OSC. The Old Stone Church is located in the Downtown area of Castle Rock in…you guessed it…an old, stone church built in the 1880’s and serves up some very tasty American cuisine and we’ll get to that but first, a sidebar:
Before deciding to eat at this place, I did descend into a personal little moment of angst. It’s the same misgiving feeling I have every time I find myself patronizing an establishment that was formerly a house of worship. I mean the place was really, truly a church and the bar is called the Chaplain’s Bar and folks can eat in the confessional…The Confessional(!), so much about that had me a-battlin’ with the Jimmy Cricket inside me. My mind was filled with thoughts of lightning and Armageddon and where would I be, probably seated in the confessional, piggishly snarfing down some (delicious) fundito. Yes, these thoughts did give me pause but then, an epiphany! I remembered that eating is, itself, invented by God, and coupled with a thankful heart can be an act of worship, too! And so, with one last check for lightning, I proceeded south on I-25 to the OSC…
Okay, back to that food. Very, very good. The photo above was taken solely because I have never seen a quesadilla quite that beautiful. All of the dishes were that well thought out, not just the aesthetics but the flavor, too! I have to give Chef Jeff Richard snaps for putting as much care into the appetizers as he does to the Sea Bass special (incredible!) and the Kobe Top Sirloin (also, incredible!). The kitchen at the OSC continued to turn out consistently beautiful, flavorful, well cooked dishes to our large party. If you stop in I would definitely give the Sweet and Sour Calamari and Pepperjack Queso Fundito (made with crab meat!) a try. Our adorable waitress knew absolutely everything about the menu (including the rather elaborate Specials), was happy to recommend a good wine, keep our glasses filled and stayed close without hovering. Also, the children’s meals were really good. I can get a little rumpled if I have to pay for dinner out and still go home and feed my kiddos because they didn’t get enough to eat or didn’t care for the greasy, bland chicken nuggets that usually grace the Kid’s Menu. Well, no problem here, both meals were prepared with the same attention all the other dishes received, with plenty of fresh made fries on the side, Yeah, Baby!
A couple of notes…the Old Stone Church is open Tuesday thru Saturday, closed Sunday and Monday. and the main dining room is a bit congested and stuffy, especially the Choir’s Loft. Also, I hear they have a great happy hour but seating in the bar can be a problem during the rush. Lastly, the OSC is pretty pricey for dinner, with the most inexpensive entrée, the Buttermilk Roasted Chicken, setting you back $18, so you might wanna save this one for Aunt Edna’s birthday or your Summer Solstice celebration or some such other special occasion. The bottom line? The Old Stone Church has very good food and very good service all stuffed into a smallish restaurant. Amen.
Sour Potatoes 